President's Letter
August, 2025
Gentlemen,
At our last gathering I mentioned an invitation that was brought to my attention by our immediate past President, Ed Wolking, to attend the “Join or Die” event sponsored by the Grosse Pointe Library at the War Memorial on October first. The title gave me a bit of a jolt but it certainly got my attention. There is nothing more significant than dying, so I was compelled to further investigate the precise nature of this invitation. It’s best that I provide an exact description of “Join or Die” as I could not do a better job summarizing its mission.
"The mission of the Join or Die event is to advocate for community connection and encourage involvement in local clubs and activities for the health of both the individual and the community. This event will feature a discussion about the documentary film, "Join or Die: A Film About Why You Should Join a Club...and Why the Fate of America Depends On It". After the discussion, attendees will be able to peruse a Joiner Fair, where representatives of all of our community's amazing clubs and organizations can hand out information and engage with potential new members. “
Attendees are invited to watch a documentary film by directors Peter and Rebeca Davis that outlines the life and the research of Harvard professor Robert Putnum. In the press notes a synopsis of the film is provided.
“Join or Die is a film about why you should join a club — and why the fate of America
depends on it. In this feature documentary, follow the half-century story of America's
civic unraveling through the journey of legendary social scientist Robert Putnam,
whose groundbreaking "Bowling Alone" research into America's decades-long decline in
Community connections could hold the answers to our democracy's present crisis.
Flanked by influential fans and scholars — from Hillary Clinton, Pete Buttigieg, and
Surgeon General Vivek Murthy to Eddie Glaude Jr., Raj Chetty, and Priya Parker — as
well as inspiring groups building community in neighborhoods across the country, join
Bob as he explores three urgent civic questions: What makes democracy work? Why is
American democracy in crisis? And, most importantly... What can we do about it?”
In the 1830s, the French government sent Alexis de Tocqueville to the United States to study penal institutions. De. Tocqueville expanded the scope of his analysis to include a more comprehensive analysis of American society, culture, and politics in his seminal work “Democracy in America”. It is impossible for me to summarize his conclusions here. Among the more salient observations he made was the degree of egalitarianism in the states, as class divisions were less pronounced than the divide between aristocrats and everyone else in Europe. He expressed concern over the possibility of a tyranny of the majority but identified several characteristics of American society that mitigated against such tyranny. The prevalence of local government and local control, a judicial system that guarantees a jury of one’s peers and the rights of individuals, and the freedom of association in all spheres of religious, civic, and private life, all served to protect Democracy. In short, the health of the individual and Democracy are bolstered in America because we were a” Nation of Joiners”.
In Robert Putnam's seminal work “Bowling Alone”, he documents an alarming reduction in the very things that De Tocqueville thought would stabilize democracy in America. From 1970 to 1990, a 40% decline occurred in the number of Americans who attended even one public meeting on town or school affairs in the previous year; a 50% decline occurred in those who took any leadership role in local organizations; a 60% decline in the amount of picnics attended annually; and among other things, a 50% decline occurred in the number of times Americans attended a club meeting the previous year. Since the publication of Professor Putnam's seminal work, the situation has only gotten worse. All one has to do is look for the white hair of those who attend religious observances to see what is happening.
Much has been said these days on the death of Democracy on both sides of the isle. I urge all members of our club to attend the showing of this important documentary film at the War Memorial on October first at 5:30 pm. The event will include a discussion with the film’s director and a Joiner Fair, where attendees can meet representatives from local organizations and clubs, learn more about them, and maybe even join them! I will be staying afterwards to man a table to recruit new members to the Men’s Club. It is my hope that some of you will JOIN me in this important endeavor.
Best Regards,
Daniel Elihue Clark